The National Green Tribunal has directed Padmavati Associates to pay ₹12,45,77,156.40 in environmental damage compensation over construction at three housing projects in Pune’s Aundh area without prior environmental clearance and the required pollution control consents.
The NGT’s Western Zone Bench in Pune issued the direction in its November 19 judgment. The amount must be deposited with the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board (MPCB) within two months of the judgment being uploaded. The tribunal has directed that the money be used for restoration around the projects.
The case concerns Pristine Prism, Pristine Royale and Pristine Privilege. The bench also gave the Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC) two months to prepare a restoration plan in consultation with the MPCB and the Central Pollution Control Board.
The proceedings followed an execution application filed by Pune resident Tanaji Balasaheb Gambhire to enforce the tribunal’s February 24, 2022 order. That order had directed a joint committee to determine liability, assess and recover compensation, and prepare a restoration plan.
The MPCB had initially assessed the compensation at ₹14.11 crore. Padmavati Associates objected to that assessment, arguing that it had not been given a hearing before the amount was fixed. The developer also argued that older violations should be excluded and that the PMC had not made prior environmental clearance a condition of its building approvals.
The tribunal adopted a different calculation, citing the Supreme Court’s ruling in the Goel Ganga Developers case. It fixed the compensation at 10% of the estimated project cost of ₹124.58 crore, a figure declared by the developer in its own filing.
The tribunal noted that the developer had applied for environmental clearance in September 2019 but had not pursued the application. It also questioned why Maharashtra’s State Environment Impact Assessment Authority had not acted after learning that construction had proceeded without the required approvals.
Environmental conditions at the sites were also recorded in a report by a Visvesvaraya National Institute of Technology, Nagpur, team following an October 2024 visit. The report found that Pristine Royale and Pristine Privilege did not have sewage treatment plants. At Pristine Prism, treated effluent was discharged into a public sewer instead of being reused.
The team also reported inadequate water conservation measures and insufficient green cover. The tribunal found that the report did not include a site restoration plan and assigned the PMC responsibility for preparing one.
The order further directs the MPCB to incorporate the developer’s own proposed environmental management measures into the conditions of its Consent to Operate. These measures include rainwater harvesting, sewage treatment, organic waste composting, tree planting and environmental monitoring.
The directions place restoration and operational compliance at the centre of the case. Their implementation will depend on the PMC preparing the plan, the MPCB receiving the compensation and incorporating the specified measures into the projects’ operating conditions. The NGT disposed of the execution application with these directions.


