India’s pollution-under-control (PUC) system may be certifying vehicles that continue to emit excessive pollution on the road, according to experts cited in a report by Jagran. They attribute the gap to outdated testing methods, weak oversight of PUC centres and the inability of existing checks to detect faults in newer vehicle systems.
The concern is particularly significant for Delhi, where vehicle emissions are a major part of the city’s air-quality challenge. Experts cited in the report said that merely changing the validity period of a PUC certificate would not address the underlying problem. They called instead for more reliable testing, stronger audits and technology capable of identifying emissions-related faults while vehicles are in use.
Vivek Chattopadhyay, principal programme manager of the Air Control Unit at the Centre for Science and Environment, said thousands of PUC centres operate across the country but do not have enough inspectors for effective supervision. He also pointed to a lack of regular audits and inadequate scrutiny of records, which, he said, creates the possibility of fraudulent certificates being issued.
Chattopadhyay recommended that private vehicles also be brought under an automated testing station system similar to the arrangements used for commercial vehicles. Such a system could reduce dependence on manual checks and create a more standardised process for assessing vehicle emissions and fitness.
The experts also highlighted the potential role of on-board diagnostics, or OBD, systems. BS-IV and BS-VI vehicles use electronic systems linked to sensors and engine components. According to the report, OBD scanning could help identify technical faults that are not visible through conventional exhaust testing. The data could also be uploaded to the national vehicle database to create a more traceable record of a vehicle’s compliance.
Sunil Dahiya of EnviroCatalysts said current checks may fail to detect problems involving nitrogen oxide emissions, selective catalytic reduction systems and diesel exhaust fluid, commonly known as AdBlue, in BS-VI vehicles. He argued that OBD scanning should be made mandatory for vehicles covered by the relevant technology and that the results should be digitally recorded.
The report also distinguishes between vehicle age and emission-control technology. Transport expert Anil Chhikara said older BS-III and earlier vehicles lack the more advanced systems used to control exhaust emissions. Their PUC validity is therefore three months, while BS-IV vehicles have a six-month validity, according to the report. Chhikara said the inspection method should reflect the age and technology of each vehicle rather than rely on a uniform approach.
He also cautioned that a BS-VI vehicle with poor maintenance could emit more pollution than a better-maintained BS-IV vehicle. In addition to encouraging lower-emission vehicles, he called for mandatory fitness checks for private vehicles similar to those required for commercial vehicles.
Remote sensing is the other major technology proposed by the experts. It can assess emissions from vehicles travelling on the road without stopping them, allowing enforcement agencies to identify vehicles that may be producing excessive pollution. The report says such equipment is being used in Kolkata and that several trials have taken place in Delhi, although a decision on wider implementation in the capital has not yet been taken.
The approach could shift emissions enforcement from a certificate-based model to a combination of periodic testing and real-world monitoring. A vehicle would still need a PUC certificate, but roadside sensing could help identify whether its actual emissions remain within permitted limits after the certificate has been issued.
The report also refers to the use of OBD and related systems in China, where a fault detected in a vehicle’s sensors can lead to a further inspection at a subsequent testing centre or checkpoint. These examples indicate how digital records and roadside monitoring can complement fixed testing facilities, although the report does not provide comparative performance data or implementation costs.
For Delhi, the unresolved issue is not only whether more frequent testing is required, but whether the existing system can reliably identify vehicles that are polluting between inspections. The experts’ recommendations point to three connected requirements: regular audits of PUC centres, testing methods matched to vehicle technology and enforcement based on both inspection records and real-world emissions. The report does not indicate that the government has approved these measures or set a timetable for their adoption.


