The Calcutta High Court has permitted the provisional appointment and training of four successful West Bengal Police constable candidates whose verification was held up after their names, or those of their parents, were deleted from the voter list during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) process. The appointments can be cancelled if the candidates or their relevant parents are not included in the voter list after their appeals are decided.
Justice Krishna Rao passed the directions in cases involving Sabana Ajmi, Daliya Afsana, Akram Khan and Abdul Hamid Sheikh, all of whom had cleared the 2024 West Bengal Police constable recruitment examination. Their verification and appointments had not been completed because of voter-list deletion issues that were pending before the Appellate Tribunal.
In Sabana Ajmi’s case, the 22-year-old candidate from Nabagram in Murshidabad had qualified for the constable post, but her verification was reportedly held up because her father’s name had been deleted from the voter list. Her own name was included in the 2026 SIR list, and the report said she had also cast her vote. In an order dated October 15, the court directed the Deputy Inspector General of Police to verify her candidature and appoint her if she was otherwise eligible.
The order included a specific condition. The court said that if Ajmi’s father’s name was not included in the voter list by the adjudicating authority or the Appellate Tribunal, the authorities would be free to take steps to cancel her appointment in accordance with law.
A similar direction was issued for Daliya Afsana, a 21-year-old from Lalgola in Murshidabad who had been provisionally selected as a lady constable. In her case, her own name had been deleted and an appeal was pending before the Appellate Tribunal. The court allowed her provisional appointment and training on October 13, while retaining the cancellation condition if her name was not restored after the appeal process.
The other two candidates were Akram Khan, 26, from English Bazar in Malda, and Abdul Hamid Sheikh from Murshidabad. Khan’s own name had been deleted during the SIR process. In Sheikh’s case, the issue concerned his mother’s name. The candidates approached the High Court after their successful examination results did not lead to completed verification and appointment.
The cases form part of a group of petitions before Justice Rao involving people who say that pending appeals against voter-list exclusion have affected appointments, counselling in competitive examinations and passport issuance. The petitions seek faster consideration of these appeals by the Appellate Tribunal.
During the hearing involving Sheikh, counsel for the Election Commission of India submitted that he fell within the category of people born after July 1, 1987, for whom verification of both parents is required under the Citizenship Act. The court’s provisional arrangement allows the candidates to move into appointment and training while leaving the final status of their employment linked to the outcome of the voter-list appeals.
The directions therefore do not amount to unconditional confirmation of the four appointments. Their continuation will depend on the findings of the adjudicating authority or Appellate Tribunal and on the candidates meeting the applicable eligibility and verification requirements.


