HomeBreaking NewsKarnataka High Court Tightens Rules for Complaints Against Officials

Karnataka High Court Tightens Rules for Complaints Against Officials

The Karnataka High Court has directed magistrate courts to strictly follow mandatory legal safeguards before proceeding with private complaints against government employees for acts connected to their official duties. It also quashed a notice issued to a head constable because the required prior approval had not been obtained from the competent authority.

Justice M. Nagaprasanna, sitting as a single judge, partly allowed a criminal petition filed by Shivashankar, a head constable attached to Bandepalya police station. The petitioner had sought cancellation of a notice issued by a magistrate court in connection with a private complaint against him.

The High Court held that recording the complainant’s statement and issuing notice to the police officer without prior approval from the competent authority was unlawful. It cancelled the notice issued by the 9th Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate Court and sent the matter back for fresh judicial proceedings from the legally appropriate stage.

The complaint was filed by M.D. Anil Kumar, who alleged that Shivashankar had used abusive language against him and others during a Karaga festival held in Mangammanapalya. The complaint claimed that the incident disturbed public order and caused inconvenience to people gathered at the event.

Based on the complaint, the magistrate court had initiated proceedings against Shivashankar under Sections 61, 109, 115(1), 115(2), 118(1), 126(2), 130 and 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. After recording the complainant’s sworn statement, the court issued notice to Shivashankar, listed as accused number three.

During the High Court hearing, the petitioner’s counsel, R. Ranganath Reddy, argued that a court could not take cognisance of an alleged offence or continue judicial proceedings against a government employee without departmental sanction. The counsel also contended that the notice requiring Shivashankar to appear before the magistrate exceeded the court’s jurisdiction.

The High Court accepted this submission and emphasised that complaints concerning alleged acts performed in the course of official duty require compliance with the safeguards prescribed by law. It said prior approval must be obtained from the relevant superior authority and the accused government employee must be given an opportunity to provide an explanation before proceedings move forward.

The court further clarified that statutory safeguards cannot be treated as a mere formality because a case is still at its preliminary stage. It directed that even when criminal proceedings begin through a private complaint, the process must continue only through the route prescribed by the legislature.

The ruling referred specifically to the mandatory procedure under Section 223(2) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. The magistrate court has been directed to reconsider the complaint in accordance with the law and from the appropriate procedural stage.


RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Latest News