The second draft of the COP31 cover decision has removed references to transitioning away from fossil fuels and weakened a commitment to increase adaptation finance, even as the conference presidency continues to promote a global electrification target.
The revised text, released in Antalya, Türkiye, on November 19, is nine pages long, compared with 18 pages in the first draft issued on November 16, according to an analysis reported by Down To Earth. References to ending or transitioning away from fossil fuels, which appeared twice in the earlier version, have been removed.
The first draft had proposed two possible roadmaps: one for accelerating a “just, orderly and equitable” transition away from fossil fuels, and another for an immediate shift away from fossil fuels alongside the phaseout of inefficient fossil-fuel subsidies. The revised draft does not retain those options.
The change has drawn criticism because countries agreed at COP28 in Dubai to transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems in a just, orderly and equitable manner to reach net zero by 2050. Climate experts quoted by Down To Earth said the revised text avoids explicitly identifying fossil-fuel combustion as the main source of greenhouse-gas emissions, despite acknowledging that global warming could exceed 1.5°C and calling for deep, rapid and sustained emissions cuts.
The presidency’s proposal to promote electrification, described as “35 by 35”, remains in the latest draft but in a weaker form. The proposal seeks a 35 per cent share of electrification in the global energy mix by 2035. The earlier draft called on countries to contribute to that ambition through nationally determined efforts. The latest version presents it as a voluntary option within a broader call for international cooperation.
Chris Bowen, Australia’s climate minister and president of the COP31 negotiations, defended the focus on electrification in an interview with Down To Earth. He said there was no possibility of keeping the 1.5°C target alive without electrification and argued that the issue was part of the same conversation as the Paris Agreement and other climate priorities.
Civil-society groups have challenged that position. More than 60 frontline organisations, led by Climate Action Network International and including WWF International, Greenpeace International, Amnesty International and ActionAid International, wrote to Bowen on November 16. The letter accused the presidency of showing insufficient leadership and argued that issues connected to the Paris Agreement had not been given adequate priority.
Climate experts cited in the report said the aggressive promotion of the electrification agenda risked overshadowing climate finance and just-transition concerns. One expert associated with Climate Action Network South Asia said electrification should not displace other priorities, while another expert associated with the Indian government said it was important but should not put key issues “on the back burner”.
India’s Union environment minister, Bhupender Yadav, had earlier indicated that India was not agreeable to the electrification pledge. The report said India was reportedly open to discussing the proposal at COP31 if it remained entirely voluntary.
The revised text has also diluted language on adaptation finance. A commitment agreed at COP30 to triple adaptation finance to at least US$120 billion annually by 2035 has been weakened. Instead of specifying the funding volume and how it would be accessed, the latest draft focuses on consultations and roadmaps.
Paragraph 45 proposes an “Antalya-to-Addis Ababa Roadmap on Adaptation and Resilience Finance”, aimed at identifying predictable and scaled-up sources of adaptation finance, including finance for responding to loss and damage. Paragraph 49 asks the UN climate change secretariat, working with multilateral development banks and other financial institutions and mechanisms, to organise annual workshops from 2027 to 2030 on access to climate finance.
Sanjay Vashist, director of Climate Action Network South Asia, told Down To Earth that vulnerable countries needed action on the ground rather than additional roadmaps. He also warned that renegotiating agreed UN decisions could damage confidence in the COP-led multilateral process.
The text has similarly reduced the emphasis on a just transition. References to “just transition pathways and workers’ rights” in the first draft have been replaced by broader language about aligning climate plans with economic development and equitable pathways.
Harjeet Singh, global convenor of the Fill the Fund campaign and founding director of Satat Sampada Climate Foundation, described the removal of explicit fossil-fuel transition language and the reduction of the adaptation-finance commitment as a regression. Meena Raman of the Third World Network said developing countries had sought stronger provisions on climate finance but were offered workshops in the revised draft.
For urban governments and infrastructure planners, the significance of the dispute lies in what the final decision does or does not establish on energy transition, adaptation and resilience finance. Electrification can be promoted as a climate pathway, but the revised text does not link that ambition to an explicit fossil-fuel phaseout roadmap. Likewise, adaptation finance is framed around future consultations and access discussions rather than a clearly specified funding volume in the latest draft.
Avantika Goswami of the Centre for Science and Environment said a section on “Concrete Solutions” offered several options for keeping the 1.5°C target within reach, but argued that the proposed pathways appeared designed to accommodate competing positions. COP31 was scheduled to conclude on November 20, leaving the final outcome dependent on the negotiations’ closing discussions.


