HomeBreaking NewsSurat Consumer Commission Rejects Insurer’s Driver Claim, Orders ₹19.75 Lakh Payout

Surat Consumer Commission Rejects Insurer’s Driver Claim, Orders ₹19.75 Lakh Payout

The Surat consumer commission has directed ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co Ltd to pay ₹19.75 lakh with interest to a truck owner after ruling that an injured cleaner’s presence inside a crashed vehicle did not prove that he was driving it.

The Surat District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (Main) also awarded ₹3,000 for mental agony and harassment and ₹2,500 towards litigation costs to truck owner Ratilal Patel. The commission ordered interest at 8% a year from November 1, 2018.

Patel’s truck was insured for an insured declared value of ₹19.75 lakh under a policy valid from September 19, 2017, to September 18, 2018. The accident took place on June 23, 2018, at about 9.30pm while the vehicle was travelling from Bodeli to Surat.

According to the complaint, the truck was near Kosamba on the national highway when its driver, Arun Vasava, allegedly panicked as a bus attempted to overtake it in a rash manner. Vasava jumped out of the moving truck, fearing an accident, after which the vehicle veered off the road and plunged into a ditch.

The cleaner, who had been seated beside the driver, was trapped inside the damaged cabin and suffered injuries. Police and the insurer were informed about the accident. An authorised dealer later assessed the repair cost at ₹21.65 lakh. Since the estimate exceeded the truck’s insured declared value, Patel sought settlement of the claim on a total-loss basis.

The insurer rejected the claim on August 25, 2018, alleging that facts had been misrepresented. ICICI Lombard contended that the cleaner, who did not hold a valid driving licence, had been driving the truck when it crashed.

Patel’s advocate, Shreyas Desai, argued that the licensed driver had been at the wheel and had jumped from the truck when he feared a collision. The cleaner’s presence in the cabin after the crash, he argued, could not by itself establish that the cleaner had been driving.

The commission accepted this argument and held that the insurer could not conclude that the cleaner was driving merely because he was found trapped inside the vehicle. It further held that the insurance company had failed to establish that Arun Vasava was not driving the truck.

The order places the evidentiary responsibility on the insurer when a claim is rejected on the basis of an alleged licence or driver violation. For commercial vehicle operators, the dispute also illustrates how the condition of a damaged vehicle, the positions of occupants and post-accident evidence can determine whether a road crash becomes an insurance settlement or a prolonged consumer complaint.

The commission’s direction requires ICICI Lombard to pay the insured amount with interest, along with the compensation and litigation costs awarded to Patel.


RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Latest News