A reported water shortfall in Thane has intensified a political dispute over whether supplies from the Surya project in Palghar district should be redirected to the city, with local leaders warning that such a move could affect other urban areas that claim the same source.
Loksatta reported on November 19 that Thane Municipal Corporation is facing a daily water deficit of 47 million litres and that a 10% reduction in supply was imposed after Diwali. The report said several parts of the city are experiencing acute shortages, while newer housing developments in the Ghodbunder area are relying on tanker deliveries.
The reported increase in tanker prices has added to residents’ difficulties, according to the article. Ghodbunder is part of the constituency represented by Maharashtra minister Pratap Sarnaik, who has sought the diversion of water from the Surya project towards Thane, Loksatta reported.
The proposal has met opposition from BJP MLA Narendra Mehta. According to the report, Mehta has argued that water claimed by Mira-Bhayandar should not be redirected to Thane. Mira-Bhayandar mayor Dimple Mehta has also opposed the move, signalling a dispute between leaders of the ruling alliance over how the regional supply should be distributed.
The Surya project is described in the report as an important water source for urban areas in Palghar district. Redirecting part of its supply to Thane could create concerns for those cities, which already claim entitlement to the project’s water, Loksatta reported. The report did not provide a government order, revised allocation plan or technical assessment establishing whether a diversion has been approved.
A separate dispute has also emerged around Morbe dam water serving Navi Mumbai and the Panvel area. Loksatta reported that Maharashtra forest minister Ganesh Naik and BJP MLA Prashant Thakur have taken opposing positions over the issue, although the report did not provide details of a final decision or the quantities involved.
The disputes highlight the pressure on water distribution across the Mumbai Metropolitan Region, where municipal boundaries and political constituencies do not match the geography of reservoirs, treatment systems and transmission networks. A decision to redirect water would therefore affect more than the city receiving additional supply: it could alter the availability expected by neighbouring municipalities and require a documented allocation and delivery plan.
For Thane residents, the immediate impact is being felt through reduced municipal supply and greater dependence on tankers, particularly in expanding residential areas. The report said the political disagreement began in mid-November and could intensify, but it did not establish a confirmed timetable for any change in Surya or Morbe dam allocations.


