HomeAnalysisMumbai roads face court scrutiny over VIP-only civic cleaning

Mumbai roads face court scrutiny over VIP-only civic cleaning

The Bombay High Court has questioned why Mumbai’s roads and public spaces are cleaned intensively for visits by important guests but are not maintained to the same standard for residents throughout the year.

A division bench of Justices Girish Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale raised the issue on Wednesday, November 18, while hearing a petition concerning air pollution and toxic-gas emissions near the Kanjurmarg dumping ground in Mumbai’s eastern suburbs, according to a report by PTI carried by The Times of India.

The bench referred to Ballard Estate in south Mumbai, where streets had been thoroughly cleaned and roads washed with water before the arrival of important guests. The judges did not name the visitors. The report said Britain’s Prince William and Princess Catherine had visited the area on Monday.

“Why should Mumbaikars not have such roads?” the bench asked the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC), questioning the civic body’s practice of presenting a temporary image of cleanliness during high-profile visits.

The court said it was concerning that a constitutional court had to address the presence of large quantities of garbage on public roads and streets. It observed that the BMC could achieve significant improvements if it applied the same level of attention consistently, rather than carrying out what it described as a short-term, two-day clean-up effort.

The court’s criticism places routine road and waste maintenance within a broader question of municipal accountability. The issue is not only whether roads can be washed or streets cleared quickly, but whether those services are delivered consistently across neighbourhoods and are available to ordinary residents without a special event acting as a trigger.

The bench said cleanliness should be maintained everywhere and at all times. It also urged the civic body and the Maharashtra government to conduct stronger public-awareness campaigns on the effects of dumping waste on public streets.

Plastic waste was a particular concern. The judges referred to plastic bags strewn across roads and said the authorities should consider stricter implementation of the ban on plastic bags. The bench also noted that large quantities of plastic are washed back from the sea during the monsoon.

These observations connect street cleanliness with drainage, marine pollution and the management of waste entering the urban environment. However, the report does not indicate that the court issued a new citywide cleanliness order or set measurable compliance targets for the BMC and the state government.

The matter has been posted for further hearing on December 7. Until then, the court’s remarks establish a clear public-interest expectation: municipal cleaning should be a regular civic service rather than a temporary response to VIP movement. The proceedings also keep attention on the relationship between everyday waste disposal, plastic enforcement and pollution concerns around Mumbai’s dumping infrastructure.


RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Latest News