India’s economic growth remains resilient, but the three near-term headwinds identified by Chief Economic Adviser V Anantha Nageswaran point to a larger challenge for the country’s cities: how to create productive employment, strengthen industrial capacity and absorb technological change while global conditions remain uncertain. His assessment places trade relations, energy prices and artificial intelligence within the same economic frame as manufacturing, investment, supply chains and jobs.
Speaking at the State Bank of India’s Banking and Economics Conclave in Mumbai on Thursday, Nageswaran described India-US relations as being in an “uneasy equilibrium” as trade-related differences persist. He also flagged volatile energy prices and what he described as the absence of an artificial intelligence play in India as near-term risks to the country’s growth momentum.
The significance of this assessment for urban India lies in the way these risks translate into the physical and institutional systems of cities. Manufacturing expansion requires industrial land, reliable utilities, transport links, logistics networks and a workforce that can move between sectors. AI-led economic change affects not only technology companies but also the employment base, training systems and service economies concentrated in urban areas.
Nageswaran said India’s development journey is unfolding against a global backdrop marked by geopolitical tensions, the weaponisation of supply chains, climate variability and competition from China’s manufacturing capabilities. He called for a rethinking of how both the private and public sectors operate, while linking the country’s longer-term ambition of becoming a developed nation by 2047 to manufacturing, foreign investment and employment suited to an AI-driven economy.
That combination makes the speech more than a routine growth assessment. It identifies a tension at the centre of India’s development model: the country needs both manufacturing and services, but each requires different forms of infrastructure, skills, regulation and urban planning. A strategy focused only on one side would leave part of the employment and production system exposed.
Manufacturing is central to that argument. According to Nageswaran, its importance extends beyond diversifying economic growth. It is also tied to economic resilience and security. India’s goods trade deficit remains around 3.5-4 per cent of gross domestic product even after excluding oil and gold, he said.
The figure points to a structural concern rather than a short-term fluctuation. Nageswaran argued that indigenisation cannot be limited to replacing imports with domestic production. Manufacturing capabilities must also be accompanied by export competitiveness. For cities, that distinction matters because industrial activity that is not competitive may create capacity without generating durable demand for jobs, suppliers and supporting services.
The speech did not set out a new urban manufacturing policy or identify specific cities for investment. It did, however, link the national manufacturing challenge to the conditions required for investment. Tax certainty and simplicity, investor protection and the availability of a skilled workforce were identified as important factors in attracting foreign capital, with stronger policies needed at both the state and national levels.
This places state governments and urban administrations within a broader economic chain, even though they may not control trade policy or national investment rules. The ability to provide serviced industrial areas, dependable infrastructure and efficient local administration influences whether national policy can be converted into operating capacity on the ground. The supplied assessment does not quantify these local conditions, but it makes clear that policy action at multiple levels will be required.
The same institutional challenge appears in supply-chain resilience. Nageswaran said India should build buffers in critical commodities and develop capabilities in smaller but strategically important components that could become choke points in global supply chains. Such components may not attract the visibility associated with large factories, but their absence can interrupt wider production systems.
This is where the geography of manufacturing becomes important. Resilience is not achieved only by announcing large production facilities. It also depends on the presence of suppliers, logistics connections, energy availability, technical skills and access to markets. The CEA’s remarks establish the need for these capabilities, although they do not provide a sector-wise or city-wise map of where the gaps currently lie.
Energy prices form the second major headwind. Volatility can affect production costs, household budgets and the viability of businesses that depend on stable energy inputs. The source material does not provide a price forecast or identify the sectors most exposed. It does show, however, that energy remains part of the growth discussion alongside trade and technology, reinforcing the connection between economic performance and the systems that power cities and industry.
For urban economies, energy volatility can also sharpen the importance of efficiency and reliability. Industrial areas, commercial districts, transport systems and public services all depend on predictable energy supplies. Yet the CEA’s remarks stop short of prescribing a particular energy policy or assigning responsibility to a specific agency. The central point is the exposure: a growth strategy that relies on expanding production must also account for the cost and security of the inputs required to sustain it.
The third headwind, AI, raises a different question. Nageswaran highlighted the employment impact of the technology and said India’s approach should go beyond frontier AI development. The focus, he argued, should include how AI could affect jobs and how the country can create both AI-enabled and AI-insulated employment.
That distinction is relevant to the structure of Indian cities. Urban economies combine technology-intensive work with large service sectors and labour-intensive activities. Nageswaran identified labour-intensive manufacturing as one source of employment and pointed to hospitality, tourism and elder care as services that could also play a role. These sectors have different skill requirements and different relationships with land, mobility and housing, but all depend on cities being able to support workers and enterprises.
The remarks also complicate the idea that India’s AI strategy can be measured only by the number of advanced technology firms or frontier applications. An economy can have a visible technology sector while still facing disruption in routine work, weak pathways for reskilling or limited access to AI-enabled productivity gains. The source does not provide estimates of jobs at risk or jobs likely to be created, so the scale of the employment transition remains unestablished in the available material.
What is clear is that AI policy, employment policy and urban development cannot be treated as separate conversations. If new employment is concentrated in a limited number of locations or sectors, existing inequalities in access to skills and opportunity may become more significant. If labour-intensive industries expand, the demand may be distributed differently across cities and industrial regions. Nageswaran’s formulation identifies the policy challenge but does not yet define the institutional framework for resolving it.
Against these risks, the CEA said India’s growth momentum remained resilient. The economy has grown 7.8 per cent, while reforms involving digital public infrastructure, inclusion, capital expenditure and formalisation have contributed to sustained growth of 7 per cent or above. These figures provide the basis for his argument that the current outlook is not one of immediate economic weakness, but of growth facing identifiable vulnerabilities.
The contrast is important. Strong aggregate growth does not eliminate exposure to trade disputes, energy volatility or technological disruption. Nor does it automatically ensure that growth produces employment across the range of workers and cities that need it. The policy question emerging from the speech is therefore not simply whether India can maintain growth, but whether growth can be made more resilient, more employment-intensive and better distributed across the systems that support urban life.
Nageswaran’s call to pursue manufacturing and services together reflects that broader requirement. Manufacturing can support production capacity, exports and supply-chain resilience. Services can absorb workers in areas such as hospitality, tourism and elder care, while also supporting higher-value economic activity. The two sectors cannot be separated from the infrastructure, investment conditions and skills systems that enable them.
The immediate institutional task is consequently wider than attracting capital or promoting AI adoption. It includes building buffers for critical commodities, developing strategically important components, strengthening investor confidence and preparing workers for an economy in which some jobs will be assisted by AI while others may be protected from direct automation. The available evidence does not show how these priorities will be sequenced or funded.
The CEA’s assessment leaves India with a clear set of questions rather than a single policy prescription. Can manufacturing become competitive without becoming narrowly import-substitution driven? Can cities and states provide the conditions needed to attract investment and support workers? Can AI be integrated in a way that expands productivity without weakening employment pathways? And can energy and supply-chain vulnerabilities be managed while growth remains high?
India’s 7.8 per cent growth and sustained growth of 7 per cent or above provide a strong starting point, according to Nageswaran. But the resilience of that growth will depend on how the country responds to the three vulnerabilities he identified and whether national priorities are translated into capable institutions, productive urban economies and employment opportunities suited to the next phase of development.


