HomeAnalysisHow a Will Can Change the Status of Self-Acquired Property

How a Will Can Change the Status of Self-Acquired Property

A self-acquired property may not always remain the beneficiary’s separate property after it is transferred through a Will. The character of the property can depend on the testator’s intention, the language used in the Will and whether the bequest is meant for an individual or for the beneficiary’s family branch, according to an Economic Times Wealth report.

The issue was considered by the Madras High Court in a dispute involving 2.5 acres of land originally owned by Arunachala Chetty. On November 10, 1953, Chetty executed a Will giving his wife, Smt Unnamalaiammal, a life interest in the land. The Will restricted her from selling or transferring it and stated that the property would ultimately go to their son, Veerappan.

The report said Chetty had not left the property directly to Veerappan because he was young and considered not sufficiently responsible at the time. After Veerappan became an adult, he and Unnamalaiammal executed a gift settlement deed on February 26, 1975, transferring the land to Smt Ganga, Veerappan’s second wife. Ganga later sold the land to an outsider in 1996.

Smt Kalaiselvi, Veerappan’s daughter from his first marriage, challenged the transaction, claiming that the property was ancestral and that her stepmother did not have the right to sell it. The Madras High Court, in its September 8, 2026 decision, held that the land was self-acquired property rather than ancestral property. It found that Section 14(2) of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, applied and that Veerappan and his mother could execute the gift settlement deed, according to the report.

The case illustrates the distinction between a property received by an individual for absolute enjoyment and one transferred for the benefit of a Hindu Undivided Family or a wider family branch. Economic Times Wealth cited the Supreme Court’s decision in C. N. Arunachala Mudaliar v C. A. Muruganatha Mudaliar, reported in AIR 1953 SC 495, for the principle that the nature of property received under a Will depends on the intention of the person who made it.

Rajani Tandale, partner at 1 Finance, told ET Wealth Online that a person owning self-acquired property generally has the freedom to decide how it will pass after death and the character in which the beneficiary will hold it. If the Will gives the property to a son for his absolute benefit, it can remain the son’s separate property. If the language indicates that the property is intended for the son’s branch or for the benefit of a Hindu Undivided Family, it may acquire the character of joint family property in the beneficiary’s hands, the report said.

The report also said that courts generally treat a silent or vague Will as transferring the property separately to the named beneficiary. However, the outcome depends on the wording of the document and the surrounding intention established in the case.

Tandale advised property owners to describe the intended character of the property clearly. A Will dealing with separate property should state that the beneficiary receives it absolutely, with the right to sell, gift, mortgage or bequeath it. If the intention is to create or preserve joint family ownership, the document should expressly refer to the Hindu Undivided Family, joint family property and the rights of descendants by birth, according to the report.

The report cautioned against using unclear phrases such as “to my son and his family” or “for his enjoyment”. It also said that a Will should not grant absolute ownership while simultaneously restricting the beneficiary from selling the property, as contradictory language may create grounds for dispute.

Other points highlighted in the report include identifying each property precisely, recording how it was acquired and explaining why it is being transferred in a particular manner. A Will must be executed with the required witnesses. Registration is not compulsory, although the report said it can make the document more difficult to challenge.

The distinction also applies where a person dies without leaving a Will. Yogendra Aldak, executive partner at Lakshmikumaran & Sridharan Attorneys, told ET Wealth Online that a Hindu father may leave self-acquired property to anyone under Section 30 of the Hindu Succession Act and that a son has no right to object merely because he is excluded.

Where there is no Will, Section 8 provides for succession to Class I heirs, including the widow, sons, daughters and mother, with each taking an equal share, according to Aldak. The report said the Supreme Court applied this principle in J. Rajesh v. M. Kumaran, treating the son’s inherited share as his individual property rather than as joint family property.

The practical consequence is that ownership disputes may turn not only on who received a property, but also on the legal intention expressed in the transfer document. For property owners, precise drafting and consistent terms are therefore central to determining whether a future beneficiary holds the asset individually or for a wider family unit.


RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Latest News