HomeAnalysisTamil Nadu’s Library Scam Exposes a Broken Public Procurement System

Tamil Nadu’s Library Scam Exposes a Broken Public Procurement System

The controversy over AI-generated books found in Tamil Nadu’s public libraries is not only a question of fake content reaching readers. It exposes a wider weakness in how public reading infrastructure is procured, reviewed and managed across the state. The immediate concern is the removal of unreliable books, but the deeper issue is whether libraries have systems capable of ensuring that public money buys useful knowledge and that readers can find it.

In an interview with The Times of India, writer Perumal Murugan said the libraries department had identified thousands of AI-generated books in libraries across Tamil Nadu. He said some of the books contained no reliable information, authorship or facts, while their prices were inflated. His comments followed the discovery of such books at the Periyar Arivulagam Library and Science Centre in Coimbatore.

Murugan also placed the controversy in a longer history of irregularities in library procurement. He referred to instances in which nationalised books were reprinted under different titles, authors’ names were changed and existing material was presented as new editions. In his account, the current problem is more serious because some AI-generated books merely resemble books without offering dependable content.

The libraries department’s identification of thousands of such books, as reported in the interview, turns the matter from an isolated discovery into an administrative question. The immediate response proposed by Murugan is that these books should be identified and removed from shelves across the state. He suggested that they could be kept aside until the matter is legally resolved and then destroyed if they are found to have no legitimate use.

That response, however, addresses the stock already purchased. It does not by itself explain how the books entered the system, who evaluated them, which procurement rules applied, or how their prices were assessed. Those questions are central because public libraries do not operate like ordinary retail booksellers. Their collections are assembled through public expenditure and are intended to serve students, civil service aspirants, senior citizens and other readers who may not have access to large private collections.

The procurement chain therefore determines the quality of a public service. If a book is purchased in small numbers, placed on a shelf and never reviewed after acquisition, the formal act of buying it can be mistaken for the delivery of knowledge. A library may appear stocked while offering readers little information that is accurate, relevant or in demand.

Reader participation is one possible institutional response identified in the interview. Murugan suggested that new books should be reviewed by readers before being placed on shelves and that poor-quality books should be returned to publishers. He pointed to Kerala, where, according to his account, local committees manage individual libraries and include readers and writers. These committees review books, conduct literary meetings and help create facilities for readers.

The proposal is significant because it shifts part of the quality-control process closer to the people who use libraries. A central department may be able to establish procurement rules, allocate funds and monitor compliance, but local readers are more likely to know whether a collection serves the needs of a particular community. A committee-based system could also create a channel for feedback that does not depend entirely on departmental inspections.

Such a system would still require clear responsibilities. The interview does not establish how Kerala’s committees are constituted, what legal powers they possess or how they are funded. Nor does it provide a tested framework for Tamil Nadu. But it identifies an institutional gap: readers appear to have limited formal influence over the books purchased for them.

The problem is not confined to the authenticity of books. Murugan described the reader experience in many rural libraries as poor and said there was no system to tell readers whether a particular book was available in another library. He compared this with the system he described in Singapore, where staff check other libraries and arrange for a requested book to be brought to the reader.

This comparison highlights the difference between a library as a building and a library as a network. A well-designed building can provide a visible public institution, but its usefulness depends on cataloguing, circulation, inter-library coordination and staff capacity. Without those systems, readers may be forced to visit multiple libraries or abandon a search altogether, even when the required book exists elsewhere in the public collection.

The same issue affects the value of spending on journals and newspapers. Murugan said that subscriptions should also be audited because many journals and books remain untouched, including material that is printed specifically for libraries but lacks quality. The claim points to a basic performance question: whether procurement is being measured by the number of items acquired or by their actual use.

The source material does not provide figures on library attendance, borrowing rates, procurement spending, rejected titles or the number of libraries affected. It also does not establish the total number of AI-generated books identified, the publishers involved or the status of any police or government investigation. Those facts will be necessary to determine the scale of the issue and responsibility for it.

What the available evidence does show is that the procurement problem has at least three connected layers. The first is content integrity: whether books contain reliable information and have genuine authorship. The second is financial accountability: whether public funds are being spent on books at fair prices and through transparent processes. The third is service design: whether readers can discover, access and borrow material that meets their needs.

Murugan called for annual and transparent procurement, with funds allocated every year for the purpose. He also proposed that the state government buy good books in bulk, citing quantities of 2,000 or 3,000 copies as an example. In his account, Kerala publishers print 5,000 copies because libraries purchase more than 3,000 copies. He argued that larger purchases could make books available across the state and encourage publication by young writers.

Bulk purchasing could make quality books more widely available, but it also increases the importance of selection and verification before an order is placed. A large order for a poor or unsuitable title would multiply the cost of a procurement failure. The interview therefore presents bulk buying not as a substitute for scrutiny, but as a policy that would need stronger scrutiny to work effectively.

The controversy also reveals the limits of treating library administration as a routine supply function. Books are not interchangeable stock. Their value depends on accuracy, authorship, relevance, language, accessibility and reader demand. A procurement process designed mainly to meet numerical targets can overlook these qualities, particularly when the people using the collection have no structured role in evaluating it.

For Tamil Nadu’s public libraries, the immediate administrative task is to establish which books were acquired, how they were assessed and whether they should remain in circulation. The longer task is to connect procurement with reader feedback, transparent records and measurable use. A digital system showing which libraries hold particular books would address one access problem, while local review committees could address another at the point of selection.

The available report confirms the existence of a serious public-library controversy and records calls for an audit, removal of unreliable books, transparent annual procurement and stronger local participation. It does not yet establish the complete scale of the alleged irregularities or the findings of any official investigation. Those details will determine whether the episode remains a procurement scandal or becomes the starting point for a wider reform of how Tamil Nadu manages its public reading network.


RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Latest News