State subsidies and cash transfers are taking a larger share of the money available to governments, rising from 16 per cent of revenue receipts in 2018-19 to 21 per cent in 2023-24, according to a report by PRS Legislative Research. The shift matters beyond budget arithmetic: state governments are also responsible for electricity distribution, urban infrastructure, social protection and several everyday services that determine how cities function.
The report, titled State of State Finance 2026-27, estimates that states will collectively spend about 1 per cent of India’s GDP, or around Rs 4 lakh crore, on cash transfer schemes in 2026-27. That is higher than the 0.6 per cent recorded in 2022-23. The figures point to a growing role for direct financial support in state policy, even as governments continue to manage infrastructure and service-delivery responsibilities.
The central fiscal question is not whether subsidies or transfers have value. Many of the schemes identified in the report support women, farmers, elderly people, widows, persons with disabilities and other beneficiaries. The question is how quickly these commitments are expanding relative to the revenue base from which states must fund them, and whether the design of these schemes allows governments to maintain essential services alongside them.
The report says subsidies grew at an annualised rate of 12 per cent between 2018-19 and 2023-24, while transfers increased by 24 per cent. Power subsidies and unconditional transfers made up the largest shares of this expenditure in several states. Together, these categories reveal two different pressures on state finances: the cost of keeping electricity tariffs low for selected users, and the cost of providing direct assistance to broad groups of residents.
Power subsidies are closely tied to the functioning of both rural and urban economies. In Punjab, power allocations accounted for 70 per cent of total expenditure on subsidies and transfers in 2023-24. In Uttar Pradesh, they accounted for 56 per cent. The report says these allocations largely supported state electricity distribution companies so they could provide electricity at subsidised tariffs to agricultural and domestic consumers.
This arrangement places the financial burden of affordability partly on state budgets and distribution companies. It can protect consumers from higher tariffs, but it also means that the electricity system depends on budgetary support to reconcile the price charged to users with the cost of supply. The report notes that the 16th Finance Commission found power subsidies across states to be understated, suggesting that the reported figures may not capture the full fiscal weight of these commitments.
The distinction between a subsidy and a transfer is important for understanding the administrative challenge. A power subsidy is delivered through a service and its price: the state compensates the distribution company or supports a lower tariff. An unconditional cash transfer is delivered directly to a beneficiary. Both require reliable budgeting, but they create different monitoring questions. Electricity support involves consumption, tariffs and utility finances, while cash transfers require decisions about eligibility, coverage and the size of the beneficiary base.
The report analysed 128 identified unconditional cash-transfer schemes for women, farmers, youth and social-security pension beneficiaries. It cautioned that this was not an exhaustive list and that actual expenditure could be higher. The schemes cover a wide range of needs. Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra, for example, provide state-funded additional assistance to farmers alongside the central PM-KISAN scheme. Haryana, Karnataka and Telangana provide financial assistance to widows, while Tamil Nadu and West Bengal provide unemployment allowances to youth.
The expansion is also uneven across states. Andhra Pradesh, Chhattisgarh and West Bengal spent relatively more on transfers in 2023-24, at 20 per cent, 22 per cent and 18 per cent of their revenue receipts respectively. Andhra Pradesh and Chhattisgarh were among the states spending relatively more on both subsidies and transfers. Chhattisgarh spent about 40 per cent of its revenue receipts on the two categories combined, the highest share among states in that year, according to the report.
The composition of unconditional transfers is changing as well. In 2026-27, transfers to women and social-security pension beneficiaries have the largest share of unconditional cash transfers. Fourteen states have budgeted to spend more than three-fourths of their total unconditional-transfer expenditure on social-security pension schemes. In Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh and Meghalaya, these schemes account for almost all unconditional-transfer expenditure. In Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu, a majority of such spending is directed towards women’s cash-transfer schemes.
The scale is particularly pronounced in some state budgets. Jharkhand and West Bengal are estimated to spend 10 per cent and 11 per cent of their revenue receipts respectively on women’s unconditional-transfer schemes, the highest shares among all states, the report says. Nine states, including West Bengal, Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, spend more than 10 per cent of their revenue receipts on unconditional cash-transfer schemes.
These figures show that state finance is increasingly being organised around recurring commitments. A one-time capital project and a recurring transfer do not have the same budgetary profile. Roads, water systems, public transport assets or electricity infrastructure may require large initial expenditure followed by maintenance costs. A cash-transfer scheme, once introduced, creates a continuing requirement for annual allocations, particularly when the beneficiary base or the payment amount is increased.
The report attributes the rise in unconditional transfers to the introduction of newer schemes and higher spending on existing ones. It cites Punjab’s introduction of a women’s unconditional-transfer scheme in 2026-27 and higher budgetary allocations by Kerala and West Bengal towards women’s schemes. Such decisions may respond to genuine social and economic needs, but their fiscal effect accumulates across programmes and years.
That accumulation is where the governance challenge becomes visible. States must decide how beneficiaries are identified, how schemes overlap, how payments are financed and how changes in eligibility affect future budgets. The 16th Finance Commission, as quoted in the report, observed that unconditional-transfer schemes tend to have a large and untargeted beneficiary base. It described them as inefficient and fiscally burdensome and recommended measures to rationalise the beneficiary base.
The issue is not limited to the size of a state’s budget. It concerns the balance between immediate household support and the institutional capacity needed to deliver services at scale. Electricity subsidies can keep tariffs affordable while leaving distribution companies dependent on state support. Cash transfers can provide direct relief while increasing recurring expenditure. At the same time, cities and towns continue to require dependable utilities, transport systems, public infrastructure and maintenance.
The available figures do not establish that higher transfers have directly reduced spending on infrastructure or any specific urban service. The PRS report, as summarised by PTI, does not provide that causal comparison. What it does establish is that subsidies and transfers occupy a rising share of state revenue receipts, and that a substantial portion of this spending is recurring and concentrated in electricity support, pensions and unconditional payments.
This makes the quality of state budgeting as important as the headline size of welfare spending. The relevant questions for future budgets will include whether states disclose the full cost of power subsidies, how they account for overlapping schemes, whether beneficiary lists are periodically reviewed and how recurring commitments are balanced against infrastructure and service obligations. The report’s figures make clear that these are no longer marginal items in state finance.
The evidence therefore points to a structural transition rather than a temporary budget variation. Subsidies and transfers have become a larger component of state expenditure, while projected cash-transfer spending is set to rise further in 2026-27. What remains unresolved is how states will combine social protection with the long-term financing of utilities and public infrastructure. The next state budgets and the implementation of the 16th Finance Commission’s recommendations will show whether governments can make that balance more transparent and fiscally sustainable.


