HomeAnalysisSRFTI Campus Violence Exposes a Deepening Governance Breakdown

SRFTI Campus Violence Exposes a Deepening Governance Breakdown

The dispute over SRFTI campus violence has moved beyond allegations of attacks on students and teachers. It now centres on who is authorised to investigate, how police intervention should operate around a public hearing, and whether institutional action is being used to manage a continuing protest rather than resolve the underlying conflict.

An alumni association alleged that police intervention forced an independent fact-finding panel to shift a hearing from a planned venue in the Lake police station area to an undisclosed location off the EM Bypass. Kolkata Police denied pressuring the organisers, while the Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute administration described the allegation as baseless. The competing accounts have added a second layer of institutional contest to a campus dispute that already involves a government-appointed special investigation team, an institute-constituted panel, student rustication and an indefinite class boycott.

The immediate disagreement is over the hearing held on November 13. The alumni association said it informed the SRFTI administration about the hearing on November 12 and invited the institute to send a representative. According to the association, more than a dozen officers from Lake police station arrived at the planned venue carrying the letter sent to SRFTI. Basab Mallick of the association said the police told organisers that the institute had instructed them to stop the event and considered it illegal.

The association further alleged that police pressured the owners of the premises, who were SRFTI alumni, to cancel the hearing. The venue was then changed at short notice. A senior Kolkata Police officer denied pressuring the organisers and said the police had learnt about the hearing through their sources and deployed personnel accordingly. The officer also said that no one turned up for the event at the original venue. SRFTI registrar Deepak Kumar, in a text message, categorically rejected the allegation as baseless.

The dispute reveals how quickly an institutional inquiry can become contested when several bodies claim authority over the same episode. The independent panel, comprising actor Ratna Pathak Shah, former bureaucrat Jawhar Sircar and writer Anita Agnihotri, heard statements from 15 students and three teachers. Twelve other students submitted video statements. Its proceedings were organised by the alumni association, which presented the exercise as a public hearing into campus violence.

SRFTI, however, has rejected the alumni-led inquiry as unauthorised, illegitimate and unwarranted. The registrar had earlier said that the violence was already being examined by a government-appointed SIT and an institute-constituted panel. The administration’s position, as reported, is therefore not simply that it disagrees with the findings of the independent panel. It questions the panel’s standing to conduct the inquiry at all.

That distinction matters because the existence of multiple inquiries does not automatically create clarity. It can instead produce competing records, competing interpretations and uncertainty over which process can establish responsibility. In the SRFTI case, the independent panel is collecting testimony from affected members of the campus community, while the SIT and the institute panel operate through processes whose details are not set out in the supplied report. The available account does not establish whether their mandates overlap, whether their findings will be made public or how conflicting conclusions would be handled.

The underlying incidents took place on September 27 and October 4. The alumni association said students were attacked on those dates, allegedly by supporters of the Akhil Bharatiya Grahak Panchayat and the Hindu Jagran Manch respectively. The allegations remain attributed claims in the report. Jawhar Sircar accused the institute of failing to protect students during the October 4 attack despite prior warnings, while deploying police to prevent the later hearing. He described this as an “authoritarian mindset”. SRFTI has not accepted that characterisation.

The institutional response has unfolded on several tracks. Police have investigated an FIR filed by institute authorities on October 15. On Monday, notices were sent to the residential addresses of six rusticated SRFTI students, asking them to appear at Lal Bazar within four days of receiving the notices. Dhivahar Muthuveeran, one of the students, said his notice had been sent to his home address in Tamil Nadu and that failure to comply could lead to arrest. That consequence was presented as his understanding of the notice and was not independently confirmed in the supplied report.

The six students were rusticated last month on allegations of manhandling, intimidating, gheraoing and heckling vice-chancellor Santosh Ajmera. The report does not provide the students’ response to those allegations or details of the disciplinary procedure followed before the rustication. That missing information is important because disciplinary action and criminal investigation are separate processes, even when they arise from the same campus confrontation. The available account establishes that both are operating, but not how they are being coordinated.

The administration has also issued a notice stating that a temporary protest dais erected by students on campus is “unauthorised” and will be removed. This step places the dispute in the physical space of the campus. A protest site is not merely a symbolic feature when classes have been boycotted indefinitely; it becomes part of the daily administration of access, assembly and institutional functioning. The report does not state whether the dais has been removed or whether the students have challenged the notice.

The class boycott is the clearest sign that the dispute has become an operational crisis rather than a closed disciplinary matter. An indefinite boycott affects students who may not be directly involved in the alleged violence, as well as teachers and administrators responsible for maintaining academic schedules. The supplied report does not quantify the number of students participating, identify the demands behind the boycott or specify whether examinations, admissions or other academic milestones have been affected.

The police role is equally contested. The Kolkata Police officer’s account is that personnel were deployed after the force learnt about the hearing through its sources. The alumni association’s account is that officers arrived at the venue with instructions to stop the event and that venue owners were pressured. Basab Mallick’s position was that a hearing at a private venue did not require police intimation. The report does not include a police document directing organisers to cancel the hearing, nor does it state whether the institute made a formal complaint about the planned event.

That evidentiary gap is central to the wider governance question. Institutions can object to parallel inquiries, and police can respond to information about a gathering, but the basis for intervention needs to be clear when the gathering concerns allegations involving the institution itself. In this case, the source material records sharply conflicting claims but does not establish the legal or administrative basis on which the hearing was treated as impermissible. It also does not establish whether the panel was prevented from meeting or merely forced to relocate, since the panel ultimately heard witnesses at another venue.

The SRFTI dispute therefore illustrates a breakdown in a common institutional sequence: an incident occurs, an authority investigates, affected people receive a process they recognise as legitimate, and the findings lead to accountable action. Here, each stage is disputed. The violence is the subject of competing allegations. The inquiry structure is contested. The police intervention is disputed. The institute’s disciplinary action has generated further conflict. The protest continues, while the administration seeks to remove its physical base.

What the evidence confirms is not the guilt of any individual or organisation, but the multiplication of unresolved procedures around one campus crisis. What remains uncertain is how the SIT, the institute panel and the alumni-backed fact-finding panel relate to one another; whether the institute will respond formally to the testimony collected; and how the notices issued to the six students will proceed. Those institutional steps, rather than another exchange of allegations, will determine whether SRFTI moves towards an accountable resolution or remains locked in a prolonged governance dispute.


RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Latest News