The Supreme Court has dismissed petitions challenging the recruitment process for 337 assistant professor posts across 43 specialities in Rajasthan’s government medical colleges, clearing the way for the appointments, according to a report by the Times of India.
A bench comprising Justices Arvind Kumar and J Vipul M Pancholi dismissed the Special Leave Petitions (SLPs), including a connected petition filed by Amit Kumar Sharma. The petitioners had challenged the Rajasthan Public Service Commission’s (RPSC) selection formula, which assigned 40% of the marks to a screening test, 20% to academic qualifications and 40% to the interview.
The dispute centred on whether a later amendment to Rule 19 of the Rajasthan Medical Service Rules, 1962, should apply to the recruitment. The amendment, notified in May 2022, prescribed a maximum 10% weightage for interviews. The recruitment advertisement for the posts was issued on November 27, 2021.
The petitioners argued that the amended rule should govern the ongoing recruitment. The selected candidates and the Rajasthan government maintained that the rules in force when the advertisement was issued should apply. They also argued that the 40:20:40 formula had been in use since 2019 and had not been changed during the recruitment process.
The Supreme Court’s decision follows an October 27 ruling by a Rajasthan High Court division bench comprising Justices Inderjeet Singh and Sandeep Taneja. The High Court had held that the rules applicable on the date of the original advertisement would govern the recruitment and that the later amendment could not be applied retrospectively. It had set aside a single judge’s order and dismissed the original writ petition.
Senior advocate Menaka Guruswamy appeared for the selected candidates. Shiv Mangal Sharma, additional advocate general for Rajasthan, defended the selection process before the Supreme Court.
Sharma told the court that appointments of the 337 assistant professors had already been initiated by the state government and that the recruitment process had been completed. He cited the need for doctors in the state while defending the appointments and the applicability of the original rules.
The ruling removes the legal challenge that had held up final certainty over the recruitment process. The immediate administrative outcome will depend on the state government’s implementation of the appointments across the relevant government medical colleges and specialities.


