HomeAnalysisKRMB Puts Palnadu Water Grid Under Approval-Process Scrutiny

KRMB Puts Palnadu Water Grid Under Approval-Process Scrutiny

The Krishna River Management Board (KRMB) has advised Telangana and Andhra Pradesh to follow the prescribed approval process before taking up construction of new water projects, while citing jurisdictional and procedural constraints in responding to Telangana’s complaint against Andhra Pradesh’s Palnadu Water Grid project.

In a letter dated November 19 to the Water Resources Secretaries of both States, the KRMB did not directly refer to the Palnadu Water Grid, assure intervention sought by Telangana or ask Andhra Pradesh to provide an explanation, according to Telangana Today. The response followed Telangana’s complaint dated November 16.

The Board pointed to Telangana’s pending challenge before the Supreme Court against the Union Ministry of Jal Shakti’s Jurisdiction Notification, 2021. The case is identified as W.P. (C) No. 666/2024. The KRMB said Telangana’s request for intervention, while simultaneously challenging the notification defining the Board’s jurisdiction, was inherently contradictory.

The Board also said its decisions are generally taken by consensus under its meeting procedure. Where consensus is absent, a matter remains inconclusive unless dissent is formally recorded. It said this consensus-based mechanism, along with the pending jurisdictional challenge, constrained its ability to act on contested matters.

The KRMB further stated that invoking Principle 9 of the Eleventh Schedule to the Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2014, to seek consequential action by the Centre would presuppose an existing Board decision that was within its jurisdiction and had not been implemented by a State.

Instead, the Board reiterated the process under Principle 7. It said new projects require prior appraisal and technical clearance from the KRMB before being placed before the Apex Council. The response therefore places procedural clearance, rather than an immediate intervention by the Board, at the centre of the dispute over the Palnadu Water Grid.

The KRMB also cautioned that the perceived availability of unallocated or surplus water does not, by itself, create an assured or legal entitlement to use it. Project-wise water allocations, it said, must be determined by the competent tribunal.

The response highlights the institutional gap created when a project dispute involves both the Board’s jurisdiction and the approval process that the Board is expected to administer. It also indicates that claims over available water cannot substitute for technical appraisal, statutory clearance or a determination of project-wise allocations. The report does not state whether either State has initiated or completed the approval steps described by the KRMB.


RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Latest News