Karnataka’s irrigation infrastructure is failing to deliver its intended benefits because projects are being planned without adequate assessment of water sources, local conditions and long-term maintenance, argues agriculture and environmental expert Shivanand Kalave in an analysis published by Prajavani.
The analysis points to a well in Medini village in Kumta taluk, Uttara Kannada district, as an example of expenditure disconnected from local need. A well was sanctioned about 25 years ago for a forest settlement located after a difficult climb through hilly terrain. According to Kalave, contractors found it difficult to reach the settlement, which already had no significant water shortage. The well was eventually dug beside a road near the foot of the Kumta-Dodmane ghat, around eight kilometres from the village it was intended to serve.
Kalave presents the incident as an illustration of how administrative spending can become the objective, rather than the delivery of a functioning water asset. He argues that similar shortcomings have been observed across Karnataka’s irrigation and rural-development systems.
The analysis identifies lift-irrigation schemes as a particular concern. Problems involving maintenance, pipelines, water availability in streams and electricity have reportedly left several hundred-crore projects unusable or underused. It also cites reports of more than ₹4,000 crore in outstanding electricity bills linked to lift-irrigation schemes, although the analysis does not identify the reports or provide a date for the figure.
One example cited is a project in Afzalpur along the Bhima river in drought-prone Kalaburagi district. Kalave says the project has not become operational despite water being present in the river, attributing the failure to poor-quality construction. The analysis argues that projects frequently receive foundation-stone and inauguration ceremonies without sustained attention to operations after completion.
Kalave also questions proposals to divert water from the Bedti river in Uttara Kannada towards Haveri district. The analysis says Haveri has more than 2,900 lakes, including about 500 in Hanagal taluk, and argues that rainfall, floodwater and local storage could be used more effectively before pursuing a long-distance project reportedly estimated at ₹8,000 crore.
The argument is based on the claim that both the Bedti and Varada river regions experience flooding during years of good rainfall. The analysis also refers to proposals to relocate 25 villages affected by flooding along the Varada river, asking whether the water causing that disruption could instead be stored and used. It cites Gadag’s Bennehalla as another flood-prone system, saying that 12-15 thousand million cubic feet of water flows away without adequate storage arrangements.
These observations point to a central infrastructure question: whether large transfer and lift-irrigation schemes are being prioritised over smaller, decentralised systems that can capture rainfall closer to where it falls. Kalave advocates the revival of lakes, farm ponds, field bunds and traditional water-management practices, along with better river conservation.
The analysis further refers to Karnataka’s share of 734 thousand million cubic feet of Krishna river water following a Supreme Court decision dated April 25, 2000. It argues that the state should have focused more strongly on storage and distribution of this water, particularly for drought-prone lakes in north Karnataka. It also says that farmers who provided land for lakes around 1985 should be compensated before new storage works are pursued.
A wider constraint is the state’s uneven rainfall and limited irrigation potential. Citing a government report, Kalave says around 70 per cent of Karnataka receives average annual rainfall of about 750 millimetres and that irrigation schemes cannot be implemented across 60 per cent of the land area. The analysis therefore calls for better conservation and use of existing water resources instead of assuming that new infrastructure alone can resolve water stress.
Storage capacity is another concern. Kalave says Karnataka has 39,173 lakes and that most are filled with silt. He argues that while reservoir desilting may be difficult, restoring smaller inland lakes could improve local storage. The analysis also links rapidly filling reservoirs to reduced capacity caused by sedimentation and questions whether sufficient attention is being given to preparing lakes to receive water before the monsoon.
The expansion of groundwater extraction is presented as a related risk. According to the analysis, Karnataka now has around 55 lakh borewells, while groundwater levels are falling. Kalave also questions the rollout of household water-supply infrastructure under the Jal Jeevan Mission where a dependable source of water has not been secured. Pipelines and meters, he argues, cannot by themselves guarantee supply if the underlying source is absent or unreliable.
The analysis does not propose abandoning major water infrastructure altogether. Instead, it calls for project selection to be based on water availability, local geography, lifecycle maintenance and measurable public benefit. Its central warning is that new pipelines, canals and lift schemes will remain vulnerable if planning and accountability stop at construction or inauguration.
For Karnataka’s towns and villages, the issue extends beyond irrigation. The condition of lakes, rivers, groundwater and distribution networks affects drinking-water reliability, agricultural livelihoods, flood management and the cost of future infrastructure. The analysis therefore places water governance at the centre of a broader question about whether public works are being designed as functioning systems or treated as completed assets once funds have been spent.


