The death of accused Ratan Sheikh in a police shooting in Birbhum has prompted the district police to explain the sequence of events, while unanswered questions remain over the use of force, search-operation videography and the handling of the investigation. The incident followed an attack in which constable Biswajit Das was allegedly shot at during an attempt to arrest Sheikh in Santiniketan on Friday evening.
Birbhum police superintendent Vidit Raj Bhundesh said at a news conference that Sheikh was taken to a brickfield in Uchkaran village, in Nanoor, after his arrest because he was believed to have led officers there to recover the firearm allegedly used in the attack. According to the superintendent, Sheikh began searching for the weapon, pulled it from a bush and fired at the police team. The bullet struck the vehicle in which the officers had arrived, he said.
Bhundesh said the police returned fire in self-defence, citing the right to private defence and the need to secure the arrested person. He added that Sheikh attempted to fire again and was injured by the counterfire. The police chief did not specify the number of rounds fired or identify the officer who shot Sheikh, saying the investigation would establish those details. He said at least more than one round had been fired from each side.
The police said Sheikh was taken to Nanoor block primary health centre after being injured. The doctor on duty declared him dead, according to Bhundesh. The superintendent said the police had tried to save Sheikh’s life by taking him to the nearest medical facility for immediate treatment.
Bhundesh said a case had been started in accordance with guidelines issued by the National Human Rights Commission and the Supreme Court for such encounters. The police explanation came amid political disagreement over the incident. CPM central committee member Sujan Chakraborty questioned the framing of the shooting and said the police were reluctant to directly describe it as an encounter. Senior BJP leaders, including Union minister of state Sukanta Majumdar and Bengal panchayat minister Dilip Ghosh, backed the police action and said armed criminals could not expect leniency while shooting at officers.
The incident has also raised questions about the procedure followed during the search for the firearm. Police sources said rules required such operations to be videographed. When asked about the recording, Bhundesh said officers were about to begin videography when Sheikh fired at the police team. The superintendent’s account did not clarify whether any part of the operation was recorded before the shooting.
Police said the incident followed information that Sheikh had joined a gathering after being released on bail from Bolpur correctional home on Friday, where a group allegedly planned another crime. A police team moved to arrest him after receiving the tip-off. Two other accused persons were later detained from Bolpur and Nanoor, according to the report.
Constable Biswajit Das, who was allegedly shot during the arrest attempt, is undergoing treatment at SSKM Hospital in Calcutta under the supervision of a panel of doctors. Sheikh’s family said the police could have taken him back to jail instead of shooting him. His sister-in-law, Champa Biwi, said the family had expected him to be arrested again. His son, Badshah Sheikh, said he had no comment on the death, citing his father’s long absence from the family.
The investigation will determine the number of shots fired, the officer or officers involved, and whether the police account is supported by available evidence. The district police have said the case is being processed under the applicable human-rights and Supreme Court guidelines.


