HomeBreaking NewsCompassionate Appointment Is Not an Inherited Job, Karnataka HC Rules

Compassionate Appointment Is Not an Inherited Job, Karnataka HC Rules

The Karnataka High Court has ruled that compassionate appointment is an exception created to protect dependants from sudden financial hardship, not an inherited employment right that can continue within a family. The ruling came in a case involving the family of a deceased driver of the Kalyana Karnataka Road Transport Corporation (KKRTC).

A division bench led by Justice M. Nagaprasanna at the Dharwad bench set aside an earlier single-judge order directing the corporation to appoint the deceased employee’s younger brother on compassionate grounds. The court said it could not create a new beneficiary category merely by considering the hardship of an individual family.

“Compassionate appointment is an exception born out of necessity, and not a right born out of relationship,” the bench said, according to the report. It added that the scheme was intended to protect a family from sudden poverty or distress, and not to preserve a job through succession within the family.

The case concerned Veeresh Mantappa Lolasar, who worked as a driver with KKRTC from March 18, 2008, until his death in service on September 21, 2023. His wife, Sunanda Veeresh, had died earlier, on April 9, 2022, and the couple had no children.

After Veeresh’s death, his mother Mantavva and her younger son, Sanganna Mantappa Lolasar, who was also Veeresh’s younger brother, asked KKRTC to appoint Sanganna on compassionate grounds. The corporation rejected the request, stating that Veeresh’s mother was 65 years old and could not be given compassionate employment under the applicable framework.

Mantavva challenged the decision before the High Court and sought appointment for Sanganna. In August 2025, a single-judge bench accepted the writ petition and directed the divisional controller of KKRTC’s Ballari division to appoint Sanganna to a suitable post matching his educational qualifications within 12 weeks.

KKRTC challenged that order. The division bench has now reversed it, reiterating that compassionate appointment is linked to immediate dependency and financial necessity rather than to a family relationship with a deceased employee. The court said the scheme’s purpose was to address the economic crisis faced by dependants after the unexpected death of an earning family member.

The bench also cautioned that compassion could not be allowed to cross the eligibility limits of the scheme. “The court cannot, on seeing a person in difficulty, create a new class of beneficiaries,” it said. The judgment described compassion as the spirit of the scheme, with law acting as its guardian.

The ruling places the focus on how public-sector employers apply compassionate appointment policies: the existence of a family relationship alone does not establish eligibility, and the exception cannot be treated as a mechanism for transferring or continuing government employment within a family.


RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Latest News