Supreme Court stays NGT’s demolition order for 29 Pune homes
In a significant reprieve for residents of Chikhali, Pune district, the Supreme Court has stayed the National Green Tribunal’s (NGT) order to demolish 29 bungalows allegedly constructed in violation of environmental laws. The stay is effective until 10 February 2024, providing temporary relief to families facing the prospect of losing their homes. The apex court has directed the residents and the Pimpri-Chinchwad Municipal Corporation (PCMC) to file detailed responses.
The contentious issue revolves around allegations that these bungalows were built within the blue floodline area of the Indrayani River—a no-construction zone defined for ecological protection. Residents maintain they were unaware of these violations, citing lapses in civic governance. “Our houses represent years of toil and savings. Demolishing them would leave us homeless,” said Mahesh Patil, a petitioner. The residents argue that the PCMC has failed to update the blue floodline since 1989, despite regulations mandating periodic reviews every 25 years.
The case highlights broader issues of urban governance and environmental sustainability. While the NGT asserts the need for strict adherence to environmental laws to prevent ecological damage, the residents argue their constructions have not altered the river’s flow or reduced its size. Recent record rainfall, they claim, did not result in any flooding of their properties, challenging the demarcation’s relevance. This case underscores the tension between urban development and ecological preservation, where outdated policies often collide with human realities.
From a sustainability perspective, ensuring updated floodline mapping and stringent regulatory oversight is imperative to balance urban growth with environmental protection. The residents’ ordeal also points to the need for better civic planning and public awareness to prevent similar conflicts in the future. As the February hearing looms, the case will test the judiciary’s ability to balance human needs with ecological imperatives.
