The Mumbai suburban railway, which claimed four lives in Thane’s Mumbra on Monday, has intensified scrutiny on commuter safety, bringing to light a 2023 Public Interest Litigation (PIL) that flagged thousands of annual fatalities on the city’s extensive rail network. This pre-existing legal challenge, which prompted the Bombay High Court to lament that passengers were being treated like “cattle,” underscores a persistent and critical issue of urban infrastructure safety.
The recurring tragedies highlight an urgent imperative for Indian Railways to implement comprehensive, equitable, and sustainable solutions to ensure safer, more reliable public transport in this bustling metropolis. The 2023 PIL, which has been exclusively accessed, painted a grim picture of safety on the Mumbai suburban railway system. According to its contents, approximately 2,000 deaths occur annually on the network. More specifically, the PIL cited that a staggering 2,590 commuters lost their lives in 2023 alone, translating to an average of seven deaths per day. These figures are not mere statistics; they represent immense human cost and profound societal impact, affecting families and communities across Mumbai and its extended suburban sprawl.
The Bombay High Court’s strong remarks, likening the treatment of passengers to “cattle,” resonate deeply with the daily experiences of millions of Mumbaikars who rely on the local trains. Overcrowding, inadequate infrastructure, and insufficient safety measures contribute to a hazardous environment where commuters are often forced to take extreme risks, such as travelling on footboards or rooftop, leading to these tragic incidents. This situation highlights a severe disparity in the provision of basic, safe public services within one of India’s most populous and economically vital cities.
The recurrence of such fatalities raises profound questions about the long-term sustainability and human-centric design of Mumbai’s public transport systems. While the suburban railway is the lifeline of the city, its current state clearly falls short of providing a safe and dignified travel experience. This places a significant burden on the working population, disproportionately affecting those from lower socio-economic strata who have limited alternative transport options. The issue of gender-neutral public spaces is also pertinent, as safety concerns impact women and other vulnerable groups differently, potentially limiting their mobility and access to economic opportunities.
Addressing this systemic problem requires a multi-pronged approach that extends beyond immediate relief measures. Investment in upgrading and expanding railway infrastructure is paramount. This includes increasing train frequency, adding more coaches to alleviate overcrowding, modernising signalling systems, and enhancing platform safety features. Furthermore, the implementation of automated door closing mechanisms, as recently announced for new and existing local trains, is a critical step, but its rapid and widespread deployment is crucial.
Beyond physical infrastructure, there is an urgent need for robust crowd management strategies and public awareness campaigns on safe commuting practices. Collaborative efforts between Indian Railways, state authorities, and local municipal corporations are essential for integrated urban planning that prioritises commuter safety and decongestion. This includes improving last-mile connectivity, developing alternative transport modes, and fostering urban development that reduces the reliance on severely overcrowded routes.
The tragic deaths on Mumbai’s suburban railway are not isolated incidents but symptoms of deeper structural issues that demand immediate and sustained attention. For Mumbai to truly evolve into a resilient, zero-net carbon, and equitable city, its public transport network, particularly the suburban railway, must transform into a model of safety, efficiency, and human dignity. The 2023 PIL and the latest incident in Mumbra serve as a stark reminder that the lives of commuters must be paramount in all urban planning and infrastructure development decisions. It is time for authorities to move decisively beyond mere rhetoric and implement concrete, measurable actions to prevent further loss of life on this vital network.
Also Read: Kashmir Sees Vande Bharat Transform Connectivity
