Kerala, the recent sinking of the Liberian-flagged container ship MSC Elsa-3 on May 25 has not merely resulted in a maritime casualty but has instead ripped open a longstanding vulnerability within the global shipping industry: the perilous practice of improper container loading and the prevalent under-declaration of cargo weight.
This incident, now under intense scrutiny, spotlights the urgent need for systemic reform in international maritime safety protocols and the pressing imperative for technological advancement to mitigate potentially catastrophic environmental risks. Captain Naveen Singhal, a distinguished Singapore-based Marine and Management Consultant and an empanelled specialist with the International Maritime Organisation (IMO), has unequivocally attributed the Elsa-3 disaster to stability issues stemming from inaccurate cargo manifests. “The vessel had begun listing to its starboard on Saturday. One of the things could be that maybe some of the container lashings were compromised, but more significantly, there is a very common practice where declared container loads are incorrect,” Captain Singhal explained. He elaborated that the weight stated in cargo manifests often differs significantly from the actual load, a deceptive practice driven by shippers seeking to reduce freight costs. This “incorrect weight declaration is an old story,” he lamented, yet one with increasingly severe consequences in modern shipping.
The ramifications of top-heavy or improperly distributed loads are dire, leading directly to capsizing scenarios. Captain Singhal underscored that this is not an issue confined to Asian shipping lanes but is a pervasive international problem, impacting operations across Europe and the United States, posing a significant challenge to global maritime regulators. While port gantries are equipped with weighing capabilities, the frenetic pace of operations—often involving the loading of a container every minute—renders comprehensive weight verification a near impossibility. This operational reality creates a dangerous loophole, allowing undeclared heavy cargo to destabilise vessels. The pathway to mitigating this critical risk, according to Captain Singhal, lies in complete automation. “All this needs to eventually be fully automated, wherein the incorrect calculations, incorrect weight declared in containers is captured right at the time when it’s lifted in the gantry so that it sends an alarm and the ship staff knows, but that system doesn’t exist today,” he noted. The absence of such integrated, real-time verification systems represents a significant technological deficit that the industry must urgently address to enhance safety and prevent future calamities.
Beyond the immediate cause of the sinking, the environmental fallout remains a pressing concern. The Elsa-3 has descended into deep waters, carrying cargo that included calcium carbide, a substance known to react with water to generate acetylene gas. While Captain Singhal suggested that any such reaction would occur at depth and primarily result in harmless gas bubbling to the surface, the broader environmental impact is still being assessed. Furthermore, the incident has seen six to eight containers washed ashore, with concerns mounting over thirteen containers reportedly containing hazardous cargo. The precise nature and grade of this hazardous material are yet to be fully ascertained, leaving a degree of uncertainty regarding potential contamination. In terms of financial liability and emergency response, the incident will primarily be managed by the vessel’s Protection and Indemnity (P&I) insurance, provided by a P&I club. These clubs cover open-ended risks that traditional marine insurers often shy away from, including third-party cargo damage, oil spills, and environmental pollution. The Director General of Shipping (DG Shipping) in India is designated as the nodal agency for coordinating the entire post-incident operation, particularly as the sinking occurred within India’s Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). The Indian government holds a pivotal role in monitoring the situation and is expected to call for a thorough investigation to be conducted by Liberia, the vessel’s flag state.
This incident serves as a stark reminder of the interconnectedness of global trade, environmental stewardship, and the collective responsibility required to navigate the complex waters of international maritime commerce safely and sustainably.
Also Read: Mumbai WDFC Demolishes 14 Pillars Sparks Accountability Debate
