A proposal to exchange a 111.12-square-metre plot owned by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) in Mulund East for a 120.42-square-metre plot owned by Mulund Gymkhana has been approved by the civic Improvement Committee, according to a report by Loksatta.
The exchange would give the municipal corporation an additional 9.30 square metres of land, according to the administration’s submission. The proposal was approved after a contentious discussion at a committee meeting reported on Wednesday, despite opposition from the Shiv Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray) and Congress members.
The BMC-owned parcel is identified as part of Survey No. 155/B/1 in Mulund East. Under Mumbai’s Development Plan 2034, it is reserved for a public club or gymkhana facility and measures 111.12 square metres. The adjoining plots, identified as Survey Nos. 173/C, 173/D and 174/1, are owned by Mulund Gymkhana.
Mulund Gymkhana had sought the municipal plot and indicated that it was prepared to transfer 120.42 square metres of its own land to the BMC in return. The proposal was placed before the Improvement Committee for consideration.
Opposition members raised questions about municipal oversight and the basis for the exchange. Sachin Padwal, a Shiv Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray) member of the committee, said that the civic body should retain control over gymkhanas in Mumbai. He also argued that members of the general public do not always receive access after land is given to such facilities, according to Loksatta.
Padwal further objected that the proposal provided only the areas of the two plots and did not include their valuation. He called for a site inspection before the proposal was approved.
The reported approval places the focus on how the BMC will establish equivalence between the two properties beyond their measured areas. The available report does not provide the monetary valuation of either plot, details of the proposed land-use arrangements, or conditions governing public access to the facility.
The case also highlights the importance of transparent scrutiny when municipal land reserved for a public facility is exchanged with adjoining privately owned land. The report said opponents pointed out that a BJP corporator from Mulund serves as the gymkhana’s vice-president. The allegation was raised during the committee debate; the report does not include a response from the gymkhana or the concerned corporator.
The committee’s approval is therefore significant not only because the BMC would receive a slightly larger area, but also because the process leaves questions about valuation, inspection, institutional oversight and the public purpose of the resulting arrangement.


