The Delhi High Court has directed the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) and the Delhi Jal Board (DJB) to jointly pay compensation of Rs 11.01 lakh each to the families of two children who died after falling into an open sewer at a DDA park in Pitampura in 2010. The amount will carry simple interest at 9% a year from the filing of the respective petitions until payment, in addition to litigation costs of Rs 1 lakh for each petitioner.
The order, passed by Justice Jasmeet Singh on petitions filed by the children’s parents, held that the public authorities had failed to take adequate precautions to protect visitors to the park. The court also rejected objections concerning the maintainability of the petitions and held that compensation could be granted under Article 226 of the Constitution where the basic facts were undisputed and negligence was apparent.
The incident occurred on 16 April 2010 near ‘Double Tanki’ in a DDA park in Pitampura. The children, identified in the report as approximately 11-and-a-half-year-old Robiel and nearly 12-year-old Arjun, fell into an open sewer and died.
The court found that the park came under the DDA’s jurisdiction, while the Delhi Jal Board was carrying out the work connected with the sewer. It rejected the DDA’s argument that it was not responsible because the civil work was being undertaken by the DJB. According to the court’s reasoning, the DDA’s responsibility for maintaining the park and protecting visitors from hazards did not end because another agency was handling the sewer-related work.
The court said that keeping a public park open for recreation implied that it should be safe for visitors. It specifically noted the need to protect children, who may not identify hazards as easily as adults. The deaths, it held, demonstrated that the safety measures adopted by the authorities were inadequate.
The DJB had argued that four- to five-foot-high walls surrounded the sewer chamber and that sufficient precautions had been taken to prevent anyone from falling into it. The court did not accept this explanation as enough to discharge the authorities’ public duty. It also noted that the agencies had initially disputed responsibility for the sewer and their respective jurisdictions.
The court said that an internal dispute between the DDA and DJB over responsibility for civil works could not prevent the families from receiving compensation. It held the two authorities jointly liable, meaning they would be responsible together for the ordered payments. The Municipal Corporation was not held liable because the court found that it had no role in maintaining the park.
The compensation for each child was calculated at Rs 11,00,627 and rounded off to Rs 11.01 lakh. The court also directed the DDA and DJB to pay the amount jointly or severally in each petition, along with the applicable interest and litigation expenses.
The order places responsibility for public-space safety on both the agency controlling a facility and the agency undertaking related infrastructure work. It also makes clear that disputes between public bodies over jurisdiction cannot override the duty to protect users of parks and other civic facilities.


