The Bombay High Court has questioned the Mumbai civic administration and Maharashtra government over the city’s waste-management system, asking why streets are cleaned and beautified for high-profile visitors but remain affected by garbage and poor sanitation for residents.
A division bench of Justice Girish Kulkarni and Justice Neela Gokhale raised the issue during a hearing on a petition concerning foul odour, waste management and pollution at the Kanjurmarg dumping site, according to a report by Navbharat Times.
The court said temporary cleaning before visits by important guests was not an adequate approach to urban sanitation. It asked why the administration could improve the city for two days during the visit of Britain’s Prince William and Catherine, Princess of Wales, but could not maintain similar standards for Mumbai’s permanent residents.
The bench said the city needed a permanent cleaning system across every ward rather than short-term efforts focused on VIP visits. The judges had visited the dumping ground on Tuesday and saw large accumulations of plastic waste, the report said.
During the hearing, the court also expressed concern over the continuing growth of plastic waste at the dumping site. It questioned why more effective action had not been taken to reduce plastic use despite the problem persisting for years.
The bench asked the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation’s lawyer why more aggressive steps could not be taken to impose a complete ban on plastic in Mumbai. It said commercial interests should not obstruct measures intended to protect the city and the environment.
The court also asked the Maharashtra government whether it had a concrete policy for restricting plastic use. It sought information on the implementation of plastic bans in hill stations such as Matheran and Mahabaleshwar, as well as details of measures adopted by other states and Union territories.
The monitoring committee dealing with the dumping-ground concerns was directed to conduct an internal audit of the site’s odour and pollution issues. The court asked the BMC to submit a report by December 7, when the matter is scheduled to be considered again.
The proceedings place Mumbai’s routine sanitation, plastic-waste control and landfill impacts under continuing judicial scrutiny. The next report is expected to indicate the steps proposed by the civic body and the state government in response to the court’s questions.


