The Madras High Court has struck down a Tamil Nadu rule that enabled the state government to prohibit the inter-state transport of rough stones and aggregates, holding that the measure was unconstitutional and beyond the state’s legislative competence.
A division bench comprising Chief Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari and Justice G Arul Murugan passed common orders on a batch of writ petitions. The bench quashed Rule 3-A of the Tamil Nadu Prevention of Illegal Mining, Transportation and Storage of Minerals and Mineral Dealers’ Rules, 2011.
The court also set aside a consequential order issued by the Director of Geology and Mining on July 27. That order had imposed a temporary three-month ban on transporting rough stone and aggregates to other states, while excluding Puducherry and Karaikal.
According to the court document cited in the report, Tamil Nadu introduced Rule 3-A through an amendment on July 9. The provision sought to regulate the movement of size-reduced mineral materials, including M-Sand, metal jelly and boulders, to maintain adequate supplies within the state.
The state had argued that the restriction was a precautionary measure intended to address excessive inter-state transportation and illegal mining. The petitions were filed by valid leaseholders and crusher operators, who contended that the state could not restrict the movement of minerals that had been lawfully excavated and for which the required royalties had been paid.
The bench held that once minerals are extracted under a valid mining lease and statutory requirements have been met, ownership vests with the lessee. It further held that Section 23-C of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, or MMDR Act, concerns illegal mining and cannot be used to restrict the transport of lawfully extracted minerals.
The court relied on Supreme Court precedents and an earlier Division Bench ruling in C Stephen v State of Tamil Nadu. It observed that the state could regulate certain matters while granting a mining lease, including maximum loads and speed limits for public safety. It could also invoke Section 4-A of the MMDR Act where applicable.
However, the bench said the state could not directly interfere with sales or impose a ban on transporting minerals beyond Tamil Nadu’s borders. The ruling stated that any state measure banning the transport of minerals to other states or restricting their sale, except as permitted under Part XIII of the Constitution, would be unconstitutional and beyond legislative competence.
The decision has direct relevance for quarry operators, aggregate processors and construction-material supply chains that depend on the movement of rough stone, M-Sand, metal jelly and boulders between states. The order does not remove other statutory requirements governing mining, transport documentation, royalties, environmental compliance or action against illegal extraction.


