Tamil Nadu public libraries are being asked to do more than store books: they are expected to support students, government-exam aspirants, older residents and readers outside major cities. Yet writer Perumal Murugan’s criticism of alleged irregularities in the procurement and management of library books points to a deeper question about public infrastructure: what makes a library useful after a book has been purchased and placed on a shelf?
In an interview reported by Dinamalar, Murugan said he had exposed alleged irregularities involving the E.V.R. Library in Coimbatore. He claimed that some books in public libraries were republished under different titles, with authors’ names changed to make them appear to be new editions. He also criticised books he described as AI-generated, saying they appeared to be books but contained no reliable information, facts or genuine authorship. According to the report, he said such books were priced highly and should be identified and removed from public-library shelves.
The supplied report does not include a government order, procurement record, audit report or response from the library authorities confirming these allegations. They therefore remain claims attributed to Murugan. But the concerns are significant because they shift attention away from the simple question of how many books a library owns. They ask whether public spending is producing a dependable collection, whether readers can identify useful material and whether institutions have the capacity to detect poor-quality or improperly represented publications.
That distinction matters in a public library system. A purchased book is not automatically a public service. Its value depends on several linked steps: a transparent selection process, accurate bibliographic information, reasonable pricing, quality assessment, catalogue visibility, physical availability and the ability of readers to find and use it. If any part of that chain fails, the library may record an acquisition without delivering meaningful access to knowledge.
Murugan proposed that books suspected of being AI-generated should be set aside until the related case is completed and then destroyed, arguing that they contain no reliable information. This is a serious recommendation, particularly because removing or destroying books without a documented review process could itself create an accountability problem. The immediate institutional requirement, based on the concerns raised in the interview, would be a process that can verify authorship, content quality, edition details and price before a book enters circulation or is permanently discarded.
The interview also raises the question of who should make those decisions. Murugan suggested that readers review new books before they are placed on shelves and that poor-quality books be returned to publishers. He referred to Kerala, where he said individual libraries are managed by local committees that include readers and writers. According to his description, these committees review books, organise literary meetings and create facilities for readers.
This model is important not because one state’s arrangement can automatically be transferred to another, but because it highlights the difference between administrative procurement and community-facing governance. A central authority may be able to purchase books at scale, but local readers are better placed to identify whether a collection reflects actual needs. A committee that includes users could also create a visible channel for complaints about missing, unsuitable or misleading material.
However, community participation would need clear rules. A reader committee would require defined responsibilities, records of its decisions and safeguards against personal or ideological preferences determining the collection. The supplied material does not establish how such committees function in Kerala, how books are selected there or whether the model has been formally evaluated. Murugan’s comparison is therefore best understood as a proposal for greater local oversight rather than evidence that a specific system should be adopted without modification.
The criticism extends beyond questionable books. Murugan said that in many libraries, including rural libraries, readers are not informed whether a particular book is available. This is a basic service failure. A library catalogue is not merely an internal record; it is the interface through which a resident decides whether a trip to the library is worthwhile. When availability cannot be checked, the cost of access shifts to the reader, who may have to travel to the library simply to discover that the required book is absent.
His reference to Singapore’s national library system makes the same point at a larger scale. Murugan said the Anna Centenary Library in Chennai was designed on the model of Singapore’s National Library, but argued that copying the building’s architecture is not enough. He described a system in which staff search other libraries for a requested book and bring it to the reader when it is not available locally.
The institutional lesson is that library networks are more valuable when they operate as networks. A reader should not be limited by the holdings of the nearest branch if another library within the system has the required book. Such a service would depend on accurate catalogues, coordinated records, trained staff, transport arrangements and a defined request-and-delivery process. The supplied report does not say whether Tamil Nadu’s public libraries have such an integrated system or identify the administrative barriers to creating one.
The profile of current library users described by Murugan also points to an access question. He said most users are students, government-exam candidates and older people. These groups may have different requirements: examination materials need currency and accuracy; students may need textbooks and reference works; older readers may depend on newspapers, magazines and comfortable facilities. A collection planned only around acquisition numbers may fail to reflect these distinct patterns of use.
The same concern applies to periodicals. Murugan called for subscriptions to magazines and newspapers to be properly audited. He said some magazines and books are printed specifically for libraries but remain unread because of poor quality. If accurate, that would indicate a mismatch between procurement and demand. It would also show why circulation, reader feedback and usage records should matter alongside the number of titles purchased.
The governance issue is therefore broader than the alleged presence of AI-generated books. It concerns the absence, or possible weakness, of a complete public accountability loop. Authorities need to know what is bought, from whom, at what price, under which selection criteria, and whether readers use the material. Readers need to know what is available, how to request missing books and where to report quality concerns. Publishers need a mechanism through which unsuitable material can be challenged or returned.
The report does not provide figures on the number of libraries affected, the value of the alleged purchases, the titles involved or the status of the Coimbatore matter. It also does not include statements from the Tamil Nadu public-library administration, publishers or other independent experts. Those gaps prevent the claims from being treated as a verified assessment of the entire state system. They also show what a meaningful public examination would need to establish: the procurement trail, the identity and quality of disputed books, the applicable rules, and the authorities responsible for inspection and disposal.
Still, the interview identifies a structural test for Tamil Nadu’s libraries. A public library is not a warehouse for books acquired through an opaque process. It is a civic service whose performance is measured by whether residents can find trustworthy information close to where they live. That requires more than an impressive building or a large collection. It requires quality control, discoverability, inter-library coordination and a formal role for the people who use the system.
Murugan’s central warning is that public libraries should not become dumping grounds for material that no one reads or can rely on. Whether the allegations concerning particular books are established will depend on documentary review and official findings. The larger question remains open: can library administration measure success not by shelves filled, but by verified content, reader access and accountable use of public funds?


